Rental property can be a major asset in a marriage. During divorce, spouses must address how to divide its value. Depreciation lowers the property’s tax basis over time, even if its market value rises. This gap can lead to taxes when the property sells. How the court handles these future taxes can affect each spouse’s share.
How does depreciation change property valuation in divorce?
Florida courts generally assess fair market value when dividing marital assets. Accumulated depreciation creates a gap between market value and the property’s tax basis. This hidden tax liability may affect how courts divide assets.
Under Florida Statute § 61.075(1)(h), courts may consider the tax consequences of property division; however, Florida case law requires proof that the sale or taxable event is reasonably certain and immediate before a court will deduct prospective tax liabilities like depreciation recapture from an asset’s valuation.
What are the tax consequences of depreciation recapture?
Under federal tax law (IRC § 1250 / § 1(h)), unrecaptured Section 1250 gain is subject to a maximum federal capital gains tax rate of 25%, plus an additional 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) for higher-income taxpayers under IRC § 1411. The actual rate depends on the taxpayer’s income and tax bracket. Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain is taxed at the taxpayer’s ordinary marginal income tax rate if that rate is below 25% (e.g., 10% or 12%) and capped at a maximum rate of 25% for taxpayers in higher ordinary tax brackets (plus potential NIIT). This tax can reduce the profit remaining after the sale.
What to consider when dividing rental property in a settlement
Spouses who divide rental property face choices that can shift tax burdens significantly. Before agreeing to keep or transfer rental property, both spouses should consider:
- The tax cost of selling the property immediately versus transferring ownership to one spouse
- The embedded depreciation recapture liability that follows the property to whichever spouse receives it
- Each spouse’s tax bracket and its impact on the recapture rate
- Other marital assets that could offset the embedded tax burden
Under IRC §1041, transfers between spouses incident to divorce are generally tax-free. However, the recapture liability follows the property to the receiving spouse, not away from it.
Reviewing tax liability before finalizing the settlement
Depreciation can affect a divorce settlement based on the property’s value, past depreciation and each spouse’s future taxes. Reviewing the tax liability before dividing the property can help avoid costly surprises when it sells. A family law attorney experienced in complex asset division can explain the options before the settlement is final.

